106. Toby Anderson

Jamie and Kristy cover the little-known disappearance of 16-year-old Toby Eugene Anderson, who vanished in Selma, Oregon, in November 1986 after a troubled childhood that included time in juvenile detention and being sent from California to live with his uncle, Elmer “Billy,” in a crowded two-bedroom trailer. The family’s account claims Billy caught Toby being inappropriate with one cousin, expelled the family for the night, and later dropped Toby at a police station—after which Toby was said to have “run away,” was signed out of school, and was never reported missing until 2017 when cousin Denise began pushing for an investigation. Denise has since raised concerns that Billy may have harmed Toby, noting Billy’s later 2001 conviction for assaulting children and his release in October 2024, and asks anyone with information to contact law enforcement. 

Sources:

https://share.google/tWy7WY9BWFdnYbKvg

https://share.google/iY2iesSqmJdOqvnRk

https://share.google/l7mF6bb34nSUwR7vh

https://share.google/pqcBP8PcvjiZEaApC

(3) Bringing Toby Home | Facebook